Wood Deck vs. Composite Deck: Comparing Prices, Maintenance, and Peace of Mind

Brian Wey
Sep 17
2 min read

By Brian Wey, Project Developer

Thinking about building a new deck? Maybe you’re picturing a summer barbecue, the kids playing outside, or even a “fun” DIY weekend with your in-laws. Before you dive in, take a step back and consider a few key things: size, function, upkeep, and price. These factors will shape not just your budget, but your weekends for years to come.

The Upkeep Factor: Composite Decking

Composite decks are the low-maintenance champs. Keeping one looking great is as simple as filling a bucket with soapy water, grabbing the hose, and spending 30 minutes giving it a quick scrub. Do this once in the spring and once in the fall—maybe an hour of your time total—and you’re done.

Your weekend isn’t shot, your back and knees aren’t screaming, and you’re free to move on to the next project… or maybe just relax with a cold drink.

The Upkeep Factor: Wood Decking

Wood decks have an undeniable charm—and their lower upfront price tag is tempting. Many homeowners see that $16,000 composite estimate and immediately think, “Wood it is!” But let’s break down the long-term reality.

A typical wood deck might cost around $8,000 to build. But maintaining it? Expect to spend $450–$850 per year on stain, sealant, brushes, and other supplies—let’s call it $600 on average. Over five years, that’s $3,000 just in materials.

Now factor in your time: sanding, staining, and sealing often takes a full weekend. If you value your time at $20 an hour, that’s $320 each year. At $50 an hour, you’re looking at $1,000. Add that up over five years, and suddenly your “$8,000 deck” is closer to $16,000—the same as composite, but with five weekends of sweat equity (and a few sore muscles) behind it.

And that doesn’t include repairs. After a few seasons, boards may warp or rot, nails may pop, and railings can loosen—all extra costs and chores.

The Long-Term View

Wood decks can be beautiful and budget-friendly at first glance, but composite decking offers predictable costs and almost no weekend maintenance. While the upfront price of composite can be intimidating, its durability and easy care mean you’ll spend more time enjoying your deck—not working on it.

Meanwhile, your neighbor Carl with the composite deck? He’s probably napping in the shade, keeping a quiet tally of your weekends spent sanding and staining.